Saturday, February 21, 2009

Twice Baked New Potatoes & Filet Mignon

As I mentioned in my previous post, we found a new butcher and got a beef tenderloin for a steal. Tonight I cut it into 8 filets and one roast. Around here, fresh filet mignon runs about $19 a lb but we paid $7.99 a lb, so trimming it yourself says a ton of $$ (even after shrinkage). I was going to post about how to trim one, but this video pretty much nails it. No I didn't go anywhere as fast as this guy.

Here are the three of the filets which we ate tonight. I could have trimmed a bit more fat off, but tenderloin is so lean already.[Quick version of what I did: I got the Big Green Egg up to 550f with a cast iron griddle plate ($12 at Lowes) and seared them 2 minutes flipped, 2 more minutes flipped, 2 more minutes flipped, and 2 more minutes then removed to rest, perfect medium rare.]

But here is the 411 on the twice baked new potatoes which is based on a recipe that I found in Southern Living (March 2007?) for Southwest Twice Baked New Potatoes. This is an amazing side dish or a great pot luck item for any special occasion.

Twice Baked New Potatoes


2 pounds medium-size new potatoes
1 tablespoon olive oil
1/2 cup shredded Cheddar cheese
2 tablespoon sour cream
1 tablespoon melted butter
2 tablespoon cream
1/2 teaspoon pepper
1 teaspoon salt (divided)

1/2 teaspoon chili powder

1 teaspoon parsley

Cut a thin slice from the bottom of each potato to form a flat base; brush potatoes evenly with oil, sprinkle lightly with 1/2 teaspoon salt and place on a baking sheet. Bake at 350° for 45 minutes or until tender. Remove from oven, and let cool slightly.

Cut a thin slice from the top of each potato and carefully scoop out potato pulp into a bowl, leaving shells intact like this.

Add the remaining ingredients to potato pulp in bowl and mash together with a fork until smooth and creamy. You can be creative here and add in whatever else you want, such as; bacon bits, green chilies, or pimento. Spoon (or pipe) mixture evenly into each potato shell, and place on baking sheet.

Bake potatoes at 350° for 20 minutes or just until lightly browned. Garnish with a dollop of sour cream and herbs just before serving.

We served the steak and potatoes with fresh creamed spinach and garlic bread for an excellent dinner, our belated 14th anniversary dinner.

Give these potatoes a shot some night when you want to do something different than the same old, same old. You won't be disappointed.

On edit: You fellow Eggers, I know what you're thinking...yes the potatoes could be done even better by doing them on the Big Green Egg indirect. I just need two eggs:)


  1. ... I feel slighty violated watching that video ...

    WHERE is the bacon!?!?!?! Aside from that (and the fact that I am positive those are not well done) they look DELICIOUS!!! : D


  2. That looks great. Did a few steaks on V-Day for myself and the wife. The weather has not been my best friend here lately. Really wanting to do some grilled oysters on a weekend sometime soon and can't wait to fire up the pit again.


  3. I hate to admit those steaks look so good. I am a vegetarian & looking at meat(mostly "on the bone") can get me feeling creepy(though I did eat it for years,so...), but those filets look wonderful. I usully prefer my potatoes in Chopin vodka,but these look good too. ~Mary

  4. I plan on trying this for dinner one night this week... Yummmmmm! Cross your fingers that it will taste as good as it looks in your photos. :)

  5. Your dinner looks amazing!

    Happy belated 14yr Anniversary!

    We will be married 14yrs in July :)


  6. This is my idea of the perfect meal. I love the idea of using baby reds for the twice baked potatoes. Great post!

  7. I find it amazing, to feel hungry for dinner suddenly at this early hour.
    Actually, what I was really thinking was How close is he to my house and how long would it take for me drive, fly, swim, to go hang with Chris and Alexis for dinner.
    Keep teasing and I'll show up at your doorstep someday~

  8. Congratulations on finding a new butcher! That really is a great price on tenderloin. Yeah, the potatoes probably would have been better on the Egg, but you've gotta work with what you have...

  9. Looks great! Now I'm itchin to go back to Italy to visit my butcher over there! And no I haven't been stealing your crockery, we must both have wives that like shopping at Pottery Barn! :)

  10. May I move in to your pantry? Or your garage? I promise to wash dishes...daily! Gosh how I'd love to be your full time sampler!


Comments are moderated and won't appear immediately.