Do you know what the best thing is about meatloaf? Having leftovers and being able to have a meatloaf sandwich later. It's in my top 5, for sure!
My All-Time Top 5 Favorite Sandwiches
- Pulled pork sandwich - smoked pork, maybe sauce (vinegar, mustard, or sweet), maybe slaw
- Kentucky Hot Brown - sliced turkey, tomato, bacon, and Mornay sauce (cheesy bechamel)
- Meatloaf sandwich - leftover meatloaf, Chipotle BBQ sauce, cheddar, onion ring
- Spaghetti Sandwich (aka the Slim Shady) - leftover spaghetti, toasted garlic bread, Provolone, Parmesan
- Croque Madame - sourdough, smoked ham, Mornay sauce, Sunnyside up egg
My meatloaf sandwich is the "I Would Do Anything For Loaf," and it consists of:
- Leftover slice of meatloaf
- Chipotle Honey BBQ Sauce
- Sliced mild cheddar
- Beer Battered Onion Rings
- Spicy pickles
- Toasted brioche bun
Here are the ones that Alexis and I made this weekend.
UPDATE: Several people have asked for it so I have posted the onion ring recipe.
Of course, the key to any meatloaf sandwich is staring with a juicy, well-seasoned meatloaf. So we started with the Cheddar Chipotle Meatloaf recipe from my second book, The Offset Smoker Cookbook.
![]() |
| Cheddar Chipotle Meatloaf pictured in The Offset Smoker Cookbook (Ulysses Press) |
Even though my second book was all cooked on offset smokers, the recipes are easily converted to a kamado-style grill like the Big Green Egg or Kamado Joe. I cooked the meatloaf for these sandwiches on one of our large Big Green Eggs.










